David Cordell
I don't do emoticons, so just read this as pleasant discourse without a hint of rancor.
Holly, Dear Sweet Holly. I am 100% certain that you were the first person on this message forum to refer to Jewishness.
Lowell innocently mentioned the irony of a (possibly) Jewish friend receiving a "Christmas" gift. I followed up with the sinister passage below that seems to have caused so much consternation:
Holly, you have addressed growing up Jewish, but even with your maiden name, It didn't occur to me (and wouldn't have mattered) that you were Jewish until we were in high school. What's in a name? Classmate Debbie Moses was not Jewish, but Dennis Mosesman, my friend at St. Mark's, was. I guess the only classmates I knew to be Jewish were children of friends of my parents. Who was Jewish in our class? I would guess there were fewer than ten, but I'm probably still clueless.
Now, if anyone feels that that passage is channeling my inner Nazi, dream on. (Wait! Wait! I feel a sudden urge to drive a tank into Poland!) Is asking who was Jewish a sign of blatant anti-Semitism? Give me a break! Political correctness run amuck.
I am truly sorry, Holly, that you seem to have felt discriminated against for being Jewish. For my mother's entire life she felt like she was discriminated against because she was Italian--vestiges of being taunted in school ("Hey, Spaghetti!") and of the early part of World War II when Italy was part of the Axis. ("Hey, WOP, whose side are you on?") I may have mentioned that my wife once found my mother crying on the back porch after a fence installer didn't follow her specific instructions. Between sobs she blurted out, "He thought he could take advantage of me because I'm Italian." (Her mistake. She should have informed him before the fact that she was actually Sicilian. Important distinction. I bet the fence would have turned out just fine.)
Mentioning the black students who were at RHS during our tenure is hardly KKK material. Indeed, nothing negative was said about them. Quite the opposite. And the underlying sentiment was that it was another time, and that things have changed. Is it better not to mention them as if they hadn't existed? Further, we also pointed out that our class went to great lengths to plan an orientation for the Hamilton Park students who were enrolling the following year.
(Remember: pleasant discourse without a hint of rancor!)
Daryl, I must admit that I have wondered about who among our classmates was gay, and I suspect that many other classmates have as well, including gay classmates (although they may have had gaydar). Is that the same as advocating pinning a pink star on their shirts? Hardly. One of my closest friends, Mark Adkins, died of AIDS. My son is gay, and I worry about him all the time. For a year he and his then-partner lived together in my house, so I think I won't accept any label of homophobia, either.
By the way, I have also wondered about who among our classmates was a Democrat. (I was on your team back then, Daryl--one of the few to support Hubert Humphrey. I changed teams once I started paying taxes.) And, yes, I have wondered about how many Episcopalians were in our class. Last week, as I watched the Grammy special on the Beatles, I recalled watching their first Sullivan appearance while at my church youth group. I can't remember exactly who was at that meeting, but I have a few names in mind. Good news: I can ask without worrying about being declared racist, homophobic, misogynist, or anti-Semitic. Well, wait a minute. There were no Jews at my church, so I guess......
Anyway, and I am not directing this at anyone on this message forum, I find it disturbing when discussion is cut off by impugning the other person's character, such as playing the race card. It is an anti-intellectual form of bullying--a clever way of saying, "Shut up," without fear of reprisal.
Have I overreacted? If you think the foregoing was an overreaction, you should have grown up at 305 West Shore and had MY mother. And please don't follow with the misquote, "Methinks thou dost protest too much." Yeah, Shakespeare is just a dead white guy, but he deserves to be quoted correctly.
|