Lowell Tuttle
Want to know about TIK TOK, but not sign up?
Here's this from a good Tech writer we have here in Houston...
TECHBURGER DWIGHT SILVERMAN
More dumb than dangerous
Wildly popular social media app TikTok finds itself caught up in digital intrigue
TechBurger
Inline Image Not Displayed
Courtesy Instagram
As the Trump administration fires shots across TikTok’s bow, Instagram releases its newest feature. Reels lets users shoot and edit videos and watch others in a scrolling feed, posing a major competitive risk for ByteDance.
Inline Image Not Displayed
Inline Image Not Displayed
Loic Venance / AFP via Getty Images
The social network Instagram made abad week worse for ByteDance, the Chinese owners of TikTok, when it rolled out a competitive service.
This has not been a good week for ByteDance, the Chinese owners of TikTok, a wildly popular social video app.
First, claiming data from the app could be siphoned to the Chinese government and become a national security threat, the White House threatened to ban it in the United States. That kicked off a move by Microsoft to offer to buy its U.S. operations, something ByteDance wasn’t wild about, but would be better than just exiting the American market.
Then, President Donald Trump said if the Microsoft-ByteDance deal indeed went down, the U.S. would expect a cut of the proceeds, just because federal pressure forced the sale in the first place.
And if that wasn’t bad enough, on Wednesday Instagram rolled out a feature within its even-more-popular app that effectively clones TikTok. Reels, as it’s called, is conveniently embedded in the camera feature on Instagram which, by the way, is owned by Facebook.
But wait: Wasn’t it just last week that U.S. legislators were excoriating Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg for copying competitors’ features in an attempt to crush them?
Wow, that’s a lot of drama surrounding an app that’s best known for a bunch of teens and twenty-somethings doing elaborate dances for 15 seconds at a pop.
Given that I'm closing in on my mid-60s, it's safe to say I'm not in the intended demographic for TikTok. Though I try to keep up with new social networks as part of my job, I’d avoided TikTok for a long time because of the Chinese connection for which it is now being targeted.
Even though TikTok is owned by Chinese company, it has a U.S.-based CEO (recruited from Disney, no less) and claims to store all its information here. Still, the administration says it is concerned about China having access to data collected on its U.S. users. TikTok swears it would never give the Chinese government U.S. data if requested, but, well … yeah.
While I’m wary, I'm also skeptical of the U.S. government's hysteria over China. A lot of claims get made about the inherent dangers in using Chinese tech, but not a lot of evidence is presented. That's true of TikTok as well. If there's really an issue, prove it, rather than merely pointing fingers and clutching pearls.
And it’s not just the Trump administration — President Barack Obama’s team also spoke ominously of Chinese tech, again without presenting detailed evidence.
(Recent reports that TikTok was accessing the clipboard unnecessarily on Apple's iPhones and iPads doesn't count. So were many other apps, including LinkedIn and Reddit. That was an iOS problem, not a Chinese spying problem.)
Against this backdrop, I decided it was time to check out TikTok for myself.
TikTok contains vertically filmed videos made mostly by everyday folk. There's an innocence to it that's appealing, even addicting. Some of what you see is very funny, much of it is lowbrow, and a lot of it is just flat-out bad. It can also be touching and moving, with emotions laid bare.
TikTok is also home of so-called “trend” videos, in which people take a swing at doing popular sketch routines. For example, one involves throwing hot dogs at people (usually women) who try to catch them with their mouths, in slow motion. Another features men pouring water into Tupperware containers to demonstrate which of their girlfriends' or wives' body parts are more prominent.
I am not making this up.
There are a few people who have harnessed Tik-Tok to create brilliant content, such as comedian Sarah Cooper, who became an internet sensation with videos in which she lip-syncs the president’s public statements.
Some speculate the administration is going after TikTok because of Cooper's success (though she's just as popular on Twitter, Instagram, YouTube and Facebook), and because of TikTok's use as a platform to organize the mass ordering of tickets for the president's June campaign rally in Tulsa, Okla.
Anti-Trump teens snapped up thousands of tickets with no plans to attend, causing the campaign to crow that a million had been “sold,” but then very few people showed up. Vengeance, not national security, is the true motivation, critics say.
Into this bizarre scenario rides an unlikely white knight: Microsoft. Although that company has focused on business rather than consumer markets lately, it is in talks to buy TikTok’s operations in the United States. Microsoft has until Sept. 15 to finalize a deal.
It's true that TikTok does collect user data, but it's the same type gathered by other social apps such as Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. How exactly could that data be used to harm Americans, who already spew all kinds of personal info onto the internet with happy abandon?
Let’s face it, China, or any other nation for that matter, doesn't need Tik-Tok to spy on us. We leave it all out there in plain sight.
(A version of this story first appeared in Dwight Silverman’s Release Notes newsletter. Sign up at houstonchronicle.com/releasenotes.) dwight.silverman@ chron.com twitter.com/dsilverman houstonchronicle.com /techburger
|